← Learn

Go deeper

Best metal seed phrase backup: what to look for before you buy

By An Honest Node · Last updated

Cartoon Grandpa Gold and Node beside the title Best metal seed phrase backup

Heads up: some links here are affiliate links. If you buy through them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

The short answer: a good metal seed backup is a plain piece of stainless steel or titanium, with your words punched or etched deep into it, and a letter grid or template cut into the metal so anyone can read it decades from now. Fewer parts is better. It must fit the number of words your wallet gave you (usually 12, 20 or 24), and you fill it in yourself. A well-made plate can survive fire and water far better than paper, but not every metal product does: some fail independent fire tests. And no plate protects your backup from someone who finds it. Educational only, not financial advice.

This is a buyer’s guide. For how to write down, store and test a seed phrase in the first place, see How to back up your seed phrase.

Heads up before the links: some links below are affiliate links. If you buy through them, a commission may be earned at no extra cost to you.

What people are actually asking

We read recent posts on Reddit, Stacker News and X before writing this. The same questions keep coming up:

  • “Is metal worth it, or is paper and a safe fine?” One r/Bitcoin thread asks exactly that, and which type people like: stamped titanium, engraved steel, or tile setups (r/Bitcoin).
  • “Which plate is actually worth buying, and what should I avoid?” Another thread asks about material quality, ease of setup, privacy, and which designs are overkill (r/Bitcoin).
  • “Can I just make my own?” A Stacker News post walks through a DIY setup with stainless washers and a stamping kit, and stresses using grade 316 steel (Stacker News).
  • “Does metal make it safe?” Not from people. As one reply on X put it, metal isn’t safe from someone finding your plate (X post).

This is the exact problem from the cartoon episode “The Seed Phrase”: Fiat Frank writes his twelve words on a bar napkin, and the napkin goes through the wash.

Paper or metal: do you need one?

Paper works and costs nothing, but Trezor notes that backups have been lost to house fires, hurricanes and simply being thrown out (Trezor). Its guidance is clear about who benefits most: if you have a single 12- or 24-word backup, it is a single point of failure, and you’ll benefit from engraving or punching it into metal (Trezor).

Metal makes the most sense when:

  • Your whole wallet depends on one backup (a normal single-signature wallet).
  • The amount has grown to where losing it would really hurt.
  • The backup will sit somewhere for years without anyone checking on it.

It matters less if your backup is already split. With a SLIP39 multi-share backup set up so that a share can go missing (for example, a simple any-2-of-3), losing one share isn’t fatal, so Trezor says metal might not add much; it suggests metal for shares kept somewhere riskier or hard to reach for a long time (Trezor). And some wallets don’t use seed words at all. Bitkey, for example, uses a 2-of-3 multisig setup instead of a seed phrase (Bitkey), so there’s nothing to stamp.

What to look for before you buy

Metal seed backup buyer checklist1. Stainless steel or titanium (never aluminum). 2. One solid piece, or as few parts as possible. 3. Deep marks: punched or etched, not ink. 4. Letter grid or template cut into the metal. 5. Room for every word your wallet gave you. 6. You mark it yourself; the maker never sees it. 7. Ship it somewhere other than home if you can. A well-made metal backup can survive fire and water far better than paper, but it does not protect against someone finding it.Before you buy a metal backup✓Stainless steel or titanium (never aluminum)✓One solid piece, or as few parts as possible✓Deep marks: punched or etched, not ink✓Letter grid or template cut into the metal✓Room for every word your wallet gave you✓You mark it yourself; the maker never sees it✓Ship it somewhere other than home if you canGood metal can outlast a fire. It won’t stop a thief.
Seven checks before you buy. Each one is explained below.

The most useful independent source here is Jameson Lopp, who has stress tested dozens of metal seed backups and published the results and his design lessons (Lopp’s reviews, Lopp’s treatise). His short list of what the ideal device looks like: stainless steel or titanium, small but thick, a single solid piece of metal, center-punched or electrolysis-etched data, and the decoding template inscribed onto the device itself (Lopp).

  • Material. Lopp says only two common materials fit the bill: stainless steel and titanium. Between steel grades, 316 is more resistant to salt than 304, and he prefers 316L for even better corrosion resistance. He is blunt about aluminum: don’t use it unless you want a pile of slag (Lopp).
  • As few parts as possible. “Simpler is better,” Lopp writes: more pieces mean more potential points of failure (Lopp). In his tests he saw fasteners melt, dissolve or seize up, and devices with many parts warp or come apart after heat and crushing (Lopp).
  • Marks that go into the metal. Punched or etched data survives; ink and light surface markings may not (Lopp).
  • A template you can still read later. If a plate uses a grid of dots, the letters or numbers that decode it must be cut as deeply as your data. Lopp has seen devices fail because the template was printed in ink or etched too lightly (Lopp).
  • Enough room for your words. Count the words your wallet gave you, then buy for that number. More on that below.
  • You fill it in, not the seller. Lopp’s first rule for choosing: avoid devices where the maker may know your private key (Lopp). Never buy a backup that arrives with words already on it, and never send your words to anyone to engrave.
  • Privacy when you order. Lopp suggests assuming your shipping details could leak, and not shipping these devices to where you live. A DIY build from hardware-store parts is the privacy-friendly alternative (Lopp).

Fire, water and corrosion: what the claims mean

Nearly every product page says “fireproof” or “waterproof.” Those are the maker’s claims, and “metal” alone doesn’t guarantee anything: several devices in Lopp’s tests got D or F grades for heat (Lopp). The better question is: has anyone independent tried to destroy this specific product, or one built the same way?

Lopp’s published method is a good benchmark for what “survives a disaster” should mean (Lopp’s method):

  • Heat: a 2000°F / 1093°C propane flame, which he describes as slightly hotter than a house fire, for 10 minutes. Then the hot device is dunked in water to mimic a fire hose.
  • Corrosion: 12 hours in 16% muriatic acid. He says that’s far harsher than most people will face, on purpose.
  • Crushing: a 20-ton hydraulic press, then a check that the data can still be read.

He grades each device A to F in each category, and he calls his grading arbitrary and not highly scientific: it’s meant to show which devices hold up best relative to the rest (Lopp). He also notes he’s tested 75 devices and won’t test many more, since most new designs resemble ones already tested (Lopp). So if a product isn’t on his list, compare its design to the checklist above.

One lesson from his notes that surprises people: the fire isn’t the only danger. Big plates and stacks hold a lot of heat, and the sudden cool-down from water can warp them and break fasteners (Lopp).

Stamping vs tiles vs punch plates

Four styles of metal seed backup comparedPunch plates with a grid are one piece and fairly easy. Etched plates are one piece and a bit slower. Letter tiles in a capsule are the easiest to fill in but have many parts that can fail. Hand stamping is robust but the hardest to do well. Ease ratings are our summary of Jameson Lopp’s design notes, not test scores.Four styles, honestly comparedStyleEase to fill inPartsPunch plate (grid)Easy, robustOne pieceEtched plateSlower, robustOne pieceLetter tiles / capsuleEasy, more to failMany partsStamped plate / washersRobust, hard to do wellVariesFewer parts = fewer ways to fail in a fire or a crush.
Our plain-English summary of Lopp’s design notes. Dots show how easy each style is to fill in, not how well it survives.
  • Punch plates with a grid. You tap a dot into the right spot for each letter with a center punch. Lopp recommends center punch or electrolysis etching over other methods, and says light strikes are easy to redo (Lopp). He calls single plates with grids for center-punched dots the best bang for your buck (Lopp).
  • Etched plates. Electrolysis etching takes longer than punching but is still low effort with great results, in Lopp’s words (Lopp).
  • Letter tiles in a capsule or cassette. Pre-made tiles are among the easiest to fill in, by Lopp’s ranking. The trade-off is many parts. If tiles get jumbled or lost, the puzzle to rebuild your words can be enormous, so Lopp says tile systems should use one tile per word with the word’s number on it (Lopp).
  • Hand stamping (plates or washers). Very robust, but Lopp, who has stamped thousands of letters, says it’s easy to miss with the hammer, get light or double strikes, or turn a letter the wrong way (Lopp). Washer builds are popular for DIY (Stacker News); just remember each washer is another part.

Many designs only ask for the first four letters of each word. BIP39 words can be identified by their first four letters (BIP39), and every SLIP39 word starts with a unique 4-letter prefix (SLIP-0039). Some plates store each word’s number on the list instead. Lopp points out that numbers are less forgiving: if one character becomes unreadable, there are more possible words it could be (Lopp).

12, 20 or 24 words: which plate fits your wallet?

Before you buy, count the words your wallet showed you. That decides what fits.

Your backupWhere you’ll see itWhat to buy
12–24 words (BIP39)Many wallets. BIP39 allows 12, 15, 18, 21 or 24 words; on Trezor: Model One (24), Model T and older Safe 3 (12)A plate with at least as many rows as your words
20 words, single-share (SLIP39)Default on Trezor Safe 3 (from June 2024), Safe 5 and Safe 7A plate with at least 20 rows
20 words per share, multi-share (SLIP39)Optional on Trezor models that support SLIP39One plate per share you want in metal
No seed wordsBitkey (2-of-3 multisig)Nothing to stamp

Sources: Trezor backup formats, BIP39, SLIP-0039, Bitkey.

The 20-word rows are for Trezor’s SLIP39 format, which backs up a 128-bit secret. The SLIP39 standard also allows 256-bit secrets, and those shares are 33 words long (SLIP-0039), so if your wallet showed you 33 words, you need a plate with at least 33 rows. Always count the words you actually have.

A few things trip people up. BIP39 and SLIP39 use different word lists (2048 words vs 1024), so a plate pre-printed for one list’s words won’t match the other (BIP39, SLIP-0039). A plate where you mark letters (A to Z) can hold words from either list, as long as it has enough rows. Trezor says 12-, 20- and 24-word backups are all extremely secure, and the 24-word length exists mainly to support the Model One’s recovery process (Trezor). So just match the plate to the backup you already have.

Multi-share backups and metal

On a Trezor, a SLIP39 multi-share backup splits your wallet backup into up to 16 shares of 20 words each, with a threshold such as any 2 of 3 or 3 of 5 needed to recover (Trezor). Any number of shares below the threshold reveals nothing on its own, which is why Trezor says manually cutting a 24-word phrase in half isn’t the same thing (Trezor).

For metal, that means deciding which shares actually need it. Trezor suggests metal for the shares at higher risk of damage, such as one that’s buried or left somewhere you can’t reach for a long time (Trezor). Each share needs its own plate, and you should record how many shares exist and how many are needed. Trezor sells a multi-share version of its plate with a section for exactly that (Trezor). Weighing multi-share against full multisig? See Single-sig or multisig?

If you use a Trezor: Keep Metal 20-word vs 24-word

Trezor makes its own plates, sized to the backups its devices create. Pick by word count, not by price:

From Trezor’s product pages: both are AISI 304 stainless steel with a black surface treatment. You punch the first four letters of each word into the steel frame, after marking them with an included pre-marking pen, using the included punching tool and a holding box. Security seal stickers are meant to show if anyone has opened it. Trezor lists them as working with the Safe 3, Safe 5 and Safe 7, and describes them as fire-, water- and impact-resistant (Trezor, Trezor). Prices and availability may change. Check Trezor’s site for current pricing.

Honest notes: Trezor uses grade 304 steel, while Lopp’s design notes recommend 316L, which resists salt and corrosion better than 304 (Lopp). And as of Nov 13, 2026, Keep Metal isn’t one of the devices on Lopp’s published test list (Lopp), so we don’t have independent test results for it, only Trezor’s own claims. What it does well is fit Trezor’s formats exactly, so you don’t have to guess whether a plate has the right number of rows. Buy from Trezor’s store or a reseller Trezor lists (Trezor). For product questions, ask Trezor Support. An Honest Node isn’t an official Trezor partner.

Still choosing a device? Our Trezor Safe 3 vs Safe 5 vs Safe 7 comparison and beginner hardware wallet guide cover that.

Filling it in without mistakes

  1. Do it alone, offline, and quietly. Trezor says to run the backup alone, mind cameras and microphones nearby, and not read the words out loud (Trezor).
  2. Mark before you punch. Check each word against the device’s screen or your paper copy before making anything permanent.
  3. Check the finished plate. Use your wallet’s built-in backup check. On a Trezor Safe 5, for example, you enter the words on the device’s own touchscreen and it tells you whether they match (Trezor). Never type your words into a website or app to “verify” them. Trezor says it will never ask for your backup (Trezor).
  4. Decide what happens to the paper copy. If you keep it, it’s one more copy to protect. If you get rid of it, make sure it’s destroyed completely.

Where to keep it

A metal plate only changes what your backup can survive. Where it lives still decides who can get to it. Lopp says to assume anyone who can get their hands on the device can read the data (Lopp). Trezor’s guide walks through a hidden home safe, a discreet spot on your property, and the real problems with burying it (Trezor). We cover those trade-offs, and how many copies to keep, in the backup guide’s where to store it and one copy or several sections.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Buying a plate made for a different number of words than you have.
  • Aluminum or mystery metal instead of stainless steel or titanium (Lopp).
  • A plate whose letter grid is printed in ink that can burn or wear off (Lopp).
  • Mixing titanium with steel fasteners, which Lopp warns can corrode over time (Lopp).
  • A secret code or custom layout only you understand. If nobody can decode it, surviving the fire doesn’t help (Lopp).
  • Storing the passphrase (if you use one) on the same plate. Trezor says to keep it separate from the backup (Trezor).
  • Keeping the plate next to the hardware wallet, so one burglary takes both.
  • Telling people about it. Trezor notes that being outspoken about owning bitcoin can make you a target (Trezor).
  • Photographing the finished plate. A photo is a digital copy, and Trezor says never to store your backup digitally (Trezor).

Make sure your family can use it

A plate nobody knows about, or can’t read, is as good as lost. Write down, separately from the plate, that a backup exists, roughly where, what wallet it’s for, and how many words or shares it has, without ever writing the words themselves into that note. The free Bitcoin Inheritance Kit walks you through that on printable pages. For the bigger picture, see A simple bitcoin inheritance plan.

What this guide can’t tell you

  • Current prices. We don’t list them; check the maker’s site.
  • How a product we haven’t seen independent tests for would hold up. We haven’t tested any of these ourselves.
  • Where the safest place in your home is. That depends on your home and who knows what.
  • Legal or financial advice for your situation.

Want to check your overall setup? Run it through the Is My Wallet Safe? check.

FAQ

Is a metal seed phrase backup worth it, or is paper enough?

Paper works, but it can be lost to fire, flood or being thrown out. Trezor says anyone relying on a single 12- or 24-word backup benefits from engraving or punching it into metal. If your backup is a SLIP39 multi-share backup set up so that a share can go missing (such as a simple 2-of-3), metal may add less, because losing one share is not fatal. A well-made metal backup survives fire and water far better than paper (not every product passes independent fire tests), but it does not protect against someone finding it.

Source: Trezor

Should I get stainless steel or titanium?

Either can work. Jameson Lopp, who has stress tested dozens of metal backups, says stainless steel and titanium are the only common materials that fit the bill. Among steels, grade 316 resists salt better than 304, and he prefers 316L. Avoid aluminum. The design matters as much as the metal: one solid piece, deep punched or etched marks, and a template cut into the metal.

Source: Lopp’s treatise

Which metal backup fits a 20-word Trezor backup?

Current Trezor devices (Safe 3 from June 2024, Safe 5 and Safe 7) create a 20-word SLIP39 single-share backup by default, so you need a plate with at least 20 rows. Trezor’s Keep Metal 20-word is built for that format, and its 24-word version is for 24-word BIP39 backups. Any plate where you mark letters A to Z can work if it has enough rows.

Source: Trezor backup formats

Are tile or capsule backups worse than solid plates?

Tiles are easier to fill in, but they have more parts. In Lopp’s stress tests, devices with many moving parts and fasteners were more likely to warp, seize or come apart after heat and crushing, and jumbled tiles can be very hard to put back in order. He calls single plates with grids for center-punched dots the best value.

Source: Lopp’s reviews

Can I buy a metal backup with my seed words already engraved?

Don’t. Lopp’s first rule is to avoid devices where the maker may know your private key. Fill in the plate yourself, alone and offline, and never send your words to anyone. Trezor says it will never ask for your wallet backup.

Source: Trezor

Sources

Educational only, not financial advice.

Researched and drafted with AI assistance, reviewed against the linked sources.

Check Your Wallet